Mobile Version
Free Internet Press
  Uncensored News For Real People

FIP Year In Review

FIP Month in Review

FIP Archive Search

Multiple Discoveries from NASA's New Horizons Pluto Mission

R.I.P. William 'Bill' Herbert Kelder - Intellpuke

Gamers Donate 37,500 Pounds Of Food To Needy

Statement From The Whitehouse Regarding The Government Shutdown

An Open Response To 'Organizing for Action'

Bayou Corne: The Biggest Ongoing Disaster In The U.S. You Have Not Heard Of

Boston Mayor Hopes Feds 'Throw the Book' at Marathon Bombing Suspect

Boston Police Closing In On Suspects

2 Explosions At Boston Marathon. 2 Dead, Many Injured.

The Press vs Citizens Rights and Privacy - Act 3

CBS News - Year In Review 2012 - 366 Days: 2012 In Review

The Guardian - 2012 In Review: An Interactive Guide To The Year That Was

TruTV - The Biggest Conspiracy Theories of 2012

Colbert Nation: 2012: A Look Back

FIP Year In Review(s?)

Happy Holidays

Welcome To A New Era!

An Open Letter To United Health Care, Medcom, And The Medical Insurance Industry In General

Whitehouse Petition To Remove "Under God" and "In God" From Currency And The Pledge.

December 21, 2012

If Hillary Clinton Ran For President, She Would Probably Be The Best-prepared Candidate In American History

CIA Director David Petraeus Resigns After FBI Investigation Uncovers Affair With High-Profile Journalist

FIP Format Update

Thank you for voting.

Live Election Results

FIP In Hiatus

U.S.-Afghan Military Operations Suspended After Attacks

Iran Nuclear Chief Says IAEA Might Be Infiltrated By 'Terrorists And Saboteurs'

Romney Stands By Gaffe

Canada's Harper Government Appeals Ontario Ruling Decriminalizing Prostitution
2012-04-25 22:31:25 (231 weeks ago)
Posted By: Intellpuke

The federal government has asked the Supreme Court of Canada to put the brakes on the decriminalization of a key prostitution law.

A 30-day stay on imposed by the Ontario Court of Appeal last month when it rewrote the pimping provision is due to be lifted later this week.

The provision was struck down last month by the provincial appeals court in a decision that also removed prohibitions on keeping a brothel.

In the federal application – which also asked the Supreme Court to hear a full appeal of the Ontario decision – federal lawyers raised the spectre of neighborhoods being frequented by prostitutes and their bodyguards.

The expiration of the 30-day delay imparted a sense of urgency to the government’s request for leave to appeal the entire Ontario Court of Appeal ruling.

(story continues below)

It stated that an imminent “regulatory void” will permit prostitutes, bodyguards, drivers and booking agents to openly go about their business.

“If the stay is not extended, the public interest, communities and neighborhoods and the proper administration of justice will suffer irreparable harm,” said the Department of Justice application.

“It does so without affording any opportunity for the various levels of government to legislate in response to address the consequences the prevent any resulting harms,” added Crown counsel Michael Morris.

However, a lawyer for the three sex workers who succeeded in striking down some of the prostitution provisions accused the government of sitting on its hands since the Ontario decision was rendered on March 28.

Lawyer Alan Young said that the government’s “11th-hour request” has made it virtually impossible for his clients to provide a meaningful response, cross-examine Crown experts or provide evidence.

“It is submitted that this late request also puts this Honorable Court in the difficult position of making a decision, even a temporary one, on the basis of a fragmented and potentially misleading record,” said Prof. Young, who teaches law at York University’s Osgoode Hall Law School.

Besides rewriting the pimping law, the Ontario court struck down a provision that prohibits brothels. It said that the two laws combine to create grave dangers for prostitutes, since they cannot congregate together in the safety of a brothel or hire staff to protect them from dangerous clients.

The court imposed a one-year delay before its brothel ruling comes into effect in order for governments and municipalities to prepare for legal brothels.

Prof. Young emphasized that any delays in executing the Ontario Court of Appeal decision add to the dangers that the court found prostitutes face.

He said the court ruling left police ample ability to act against violent or exploitive pimps. It also noted that police have other investigative tools to prevent human smuggling or the exploitation of underage prostitutes.

In application seeking leave to appeal, Morris said the decision represents “a fundamental shift in criminal law and social policy,” necessitating the Supreme Court making a final decision.

It said that the litigation goes to the heart of Parliament’s ability to create and enforce laws dealing with complex social problems.

It said that the prostitution laws will be applied inconsistently from one province to another – a situation that cannot be allowed to develop.

“It also has a direct impact on both police investigations and prosecutions in Ontario, and an indirect impact upon these outside Ontario, since the judgment may create uncertainty in the validity of these provisions outside Ontario,” said the federal brief.

Intellpuke: You can read this article by Globe and Mail Justice Reporter Kirk Makin, reporting from Toronto, Ontario, Canada, in context here:

Email To A Friend
Email this story to a friend:
Your Name:
Their Email:
Readers Comments
Add your own comment.
(Anonymous commenting now enabled.)

Creative Commons License
Free Internet Press is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License. You may reuse or distribute original works on this site, with attribution per the above license.

Any mirrored or quoted materials may be copyright their respective authors, publications, or outlets, as shown on their publication, indicated by the link in the news story. Such works are used under the fair use doctrine of United States copyright law. Should any materials be found overused or objectionable to the copyright holder, notification should be sent to, and the work will be removed and replaced with such notification.

Please email with any questions.

Our Privacy Policy can be viewed at

XML/RSS/RDF Newsfeed Syndication XML/RSS/RDF Newsfeed Syndication:

XML/RSS/RDF Newsfeed Syndication XML News Sitemap