What a difference three
months makes. Back in November, the world broadly agreed that emissions
of carbon dioxide were heating up the planet and that we needed to do
something about it, even if we couldn't agree exactly what. And though
we'd had the usual pre-summit rollercoaster ride of dire predictions
and naive exhortations (yes, I plead guilty to some of those), even
hardheaded types dared to hope that Copenhagen might produce the basis
of a global climate treaty.
As late as December 7, 56 newspapers around the world could declare in in a common, Guardian-led editorial: "The politicians in Copenhagen have the power to shape history's
judgment on this generation: one that saw a challenge and rose to it,
or one so stupid that we saw calamity coming but did nothing to avert
it."
Now, with climate science under siege and climate politics
in disarray, that sounds like the rhetoric of another age. The American
commentator Walter Russell Mead recently captured the mood: "The global warming movement as we have known it is dead … basically,
Sarah Palin 1, Al Gore zip." A senior British diplomat compares those
trying to secure global action on climate change post-Copenhagen to
"small groups wandering in different directions around the battlefield
like a beaten army". A leading scientist offers an equally pithy
assessment: "Everybody is completely clueless."
Not depressed yet? This weekend a BBC poll showed a dramatic fall in the number of people who believe warming is
happening; carbon markets have tumbled; a Guardian survey of over 30
leading figures involved in climate negotiations found almost none who
believed a global deal was possible this year; in Australia a man who
described climate change as "absolute crap" could soon be prime
minister.
What went wrong? How long have you got: the leak of the
"climategate" emails that showed scientists behaving just as tribally
as their detractors, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's
great glacier meltdown (enough "gates" for now), the abject failure of
Copenhagen, Obama's Massachusetts disaster and a bitterly cold winter
in much of Europe and the U.S. If you doubt the effect of the last of
these, take a look at stories like "The mini-ice age starts here" in
the Daily Mail, or the website entitled If Global warming Is Real Then Why Is It Cold?. Add to that lot a mildly hysterical binary culture in which the case
for action on climate change is either unanswerable or in tatters, and
the perfect storm is complete.